IR: Consider two DISubprograms to be odr-equal if they have the same template parameters.
In ValueMapper we create new operands for MDNodes and rely on MDNode::replaceWithUniqued to create a new MDNode with the specified operands. However this doesn't always actually happen correctly for DISubprograms because when we uniquify the new node, we only odr-compare it with existing nodes (MDNodeSubsetEqualImpl<DISubprogram>::isDeclarationOfODRMember). Although the TemplateParameters field can refer to a distinct DICompileUnit via DITemplateTypeParameter::type -> DICompositeType::scope -> DISubprogram::unit, it is not currently included in the odr comparison. As a result, we can end up getting our original DISubprogram back, which means we will have a cloned module referring to the DICompileUnit in the original module, which causes a verification error. The fix I implemented was to consider TemplateParameters to be one of the odr-equal properties. But I'm a little uncomfortable with this. In general it seems unsound to rely on distinct MDNodes never being reachable from nodes which we only check odr-equality of. My only long term suggestion would be to separate odr-uniquing from full uniquing. Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D29240 llvm-svn: 294240
Loading
Please sign in to comment